Skip to content

Investing basics

SIP vs lumpsum: which grows more, and when each makes sense

2 min read

₹12 lakh invested as a lumpsum at 12% for 10 years grows to about ₹37.3 lakh; the same ₹12 lakh as a ₹10,000 monthly SIP grows to about ₹23.2 lakh. Why the gap exists, what it hides, and how to choose.

A lumpsum invests all your money on day one; a SIP (systematic investment plan) invests a fixed amount every month. At the same constant return, a lumpsum always ends higher, because every rupee stays invested for the full period. A SIP's advantage is about risk and cash flow, not a higher number on a calculator.

The same ₹12 lakh, two ways

Illustration with assumed inputs: a 12% constant annual return over 10 years, no costs or taxes. These are not forecasts; real returns vary year to year.

₹12 lakh over 10 years at an assumed 12% a year
LumpsumSIP
How it is invested₹12,00,000 on day one₹10,000 a month for 120 months
Total invested₹12,00,000₹12,00,000
Value after 10 yearsabout ₹37,27,018about ₹23,23,391
Average time each rupee is invested10 yearsabout 5 years

Why the lumpsum looks so much bigger

In the SIP, the first instalment compounds for 10 years but the last one for only a month, so on average the money is invested for about half the period. That, not any flaw in SIPs, explains most of the gap.

The comparison is only fair when you actually have the full amount today. If the ₹12 lakh will come from your salary over 10 years, a lumpsum is not an option, and the real choice is between a SIP and not investing.

What the constant-return example hides

  • Timing risk: a lumpsum invested just before a market fall takes the full fall on all of the money. A SIP spreads purchases across many prices.
  • Rupee cost averaging: a fixed SIP buys more units when prices are low and fewer when they are high. It lowers the risk of buying everything at a peak; it does not guarantee a higher return.
  • Behaviour: a monthly SIP is easier to keep going through a downturn than a decision to put a large sum in at once.

SIP vs lumpsum at a glance

QuestionLumpsumSIP
Best whenYou already hold the full amountYou invest from regular income
Higher value if returns are steadyYesNo
Exposure to a fall right after investingAll of the moneyOnly what is invested so far
Middle pathPark the amount in a liquid fund and move it in monthly (a systematic transfer plan)Raise the SIP every year (a step-up SIP)

Try your own numbers

Use the Fistotex SIP calculator and lumpsum calculator with the same total amount and several return rates, including low ones. The step-up SIP calculator shows how raising the SIP each year narrows the gap.

This article is educational, is not investment, tax or legal advice, and does not recommend any fund or strategy. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks.

Sources