Why is silver falling despite a supply deficit? The November 2026 demand picture
·4 min read
Silver fell despite a projected 35-million-ounce annual deficit. How weaker solar demand, investment flows and existing stocks explain the difference.
Silver can fall in price even when annual demand is estimated to exceed supply. That is the apparent contradiction behind the latest silver-price headlines. Reuters' completed 20 November 2026 global-market report put spot silver at $40.95 per ounce, down 4.22% in its reported snapshot. Yet the Silver Institute's 12 November update still projected a 35-million-ounce silver-market deficit for 2026.
The two figures answer different questions. A spot quote describes a market price at a stated time. An annual deficit compares estimated flows of supply and demand across a whole year. It is not a statement that no silver remains in vaults, that every buyer faces a shortage, or that the price cannot fall. The distinction matters more than treating the word deficit as a guaranteed price floor.
What does the Silver Institute's 35-million-ounce deficit mean?
The Silver Institute published the update on 12 November, presenting estimates from Metals Focus. It projected total 2026 demand of 1.08 billion ounces, down 5% year on year, while still expecting demand to exceed supply by 35 million ounces. These are attributed full-year estimates, not final audited totals or a fresh forecast made by Fistotex.
An annual flow shortfall can be met partly by metal already held above ground. CME Group's precious-metals education material explains that mining and recycling are not the only metal available to the market: bars accumulated in vaults can also become supply. Investment holders can be net buyers or net sellers. Their willingness to release metal changes what is available without requiring a new mine to open.
The Institute's November update makes that distinction concrete. It says the narrower shortfall and metal released through exchange-traded product selling have helped ease physical-market tightness. A projected sixth consecutive annual deficit and an easing of immediate tightness are therefore not mutually exclusive.
Solar demand and other industrial demand are moving differently
Silver has both industrial uses and an investment market. A single claim that industrial demand is strong or weak hides important differences. The Institute estimates total industrial demand at 640 million ounces in 2026, down 3%, but industrial demand excluding photovoltaics at 492 million ounces, up 4.5%. Photovoltaics, or PV, refers here to solar-cell applications.
In the solar segment, the Institute says installations have fallen short of expectations, particularly in China, while high silver prices have accelerated thrifting and substitution. Thrifting means using less silver for a given application; substitution means replacing some of it with other materials. More interest in solar energy does not automatically translate into proportionately more silver consumption.
Outside PV, the same update describes resilient automotive use, supported by vehicle electrification and charging infrastructure. This is why a decline in the total industrial estimate should not be rewritten as a collapse in every industrial use. Nor should growth outside solar be presented as proof that total industrial demand is rising.
Metals Focus estimates published by the Silver Institute on 12 November 2026. All figures refer to full-year 2026 expectations, not completed-year results. Moz means million ounces; changes are year on year.
Demand measure
2026 estimate
Change
Total silver demand
1.08 billion ounces
-5%
Total industrial demand
640 Moz
-3%
Industrial demand excluding PV
492 Moz
+4.5%
Bar and coin demand
215 Moz
-2%
Jewellery / silverware
No ounce total used here
-22% / -17%
Swipe sideways to see all columns
Jewellery demand, bar buying and exchange-traded holdings are separate
The Institute expects global silver jewellery demand to fall 22% and silverware demand to fall 17% in 2026. It links part of the weakness to high prices and weaker rural spending in India, which encourage smaller and lighter purchases. It also notes changing preferences in China and subdued jewellery demand in Europe and the US. These are segment-specific explanations, not a claim that every Indian buyer has stopped purchasing silver.
Its bar-and-coin section separately projects Indian demand down 10% for the year. That figure belongs to physical investment in the bar-and-coin discussion; it should not be labelled a 10% fall in all Indian silver demand. Upstox's 21 November coverage brings the current retail-price discussion and these demand estimates together, but this explainer keeps their measurement bases separate.
Exchange-traded products are another channel. The Institute reports global silver ETP holdings of 1.25 billion ounces on 3 November, down 4% from the start of the year, while also noting a 24-million-ounce recovery since end-June. Both observations can be true because their starting dates differ. Holdings are a stock at a date; annual bar-and-coin demand and annual mine output are flows over a period. They should not be added together as if they were the same measure.
Why the daily price still responds to financial conditions
Reuters' late 20 November report describes a broad equity sell-off, a rally in US government bonds and further falls in gold and silver. Its reported 10-year Treasury yield fell during that session. It would therefore be wrong to explain that particular late-session silver quote by claiming Treasury yields rose that day. A longer-running concern about high rates and a daily change in yields are different observations.
FOREX.com's 20 November market analysis also distinguishes annual silver deficits from immediate price support, discussing above-ground stocks and investment-related metal releases. That is market analysis, not proof assigning a precise percentage of the daily fall to each driver. This article does not adopt its trading levels or directional recommendations.
The useful reading is narrower: annual balance estimates, the mix of industrial and jewellery demand, stored metal and investor positioning can move differently at the same time. None of these facts fixes the next silver price or a recovery date. The Reuters quote is a dated US-dollar snapshot, not a live Indian retail price; domestic prices also have their own units, purity, tax and market basis. This is an explanation of the evidence, not advice to buy or sell.