Skip to content

Economy & data

Yes Bank AT-1 bonds: what the Supreme Court's 15 October 2026 judgment says, and what the 13 November review petition is

6 min read

Yes Bank has asked the Supreme Court to review its 15 October 2026 ruling on the Rs 8,415 crore AT-1 bond write-down. What the judgment decided, in plain terms, with dated sources.

What happened, in short

On 13 November 2026 (a Friday), Yes Bank told the stock exchanges that it has filed a review petition under Article 137 of the Constitution in the Supreme Court. The petition seeks review of the Court's judgment and order of 15 October 2026 on the write-down of additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds aggregating Rs 8,415 crore. This is the bank's own wording, as quoted by Livemint on 13 November 2026.

The 15 October judgment (reported as 2026 INSC 1132) dismissed the appeals of Yes Bank, the Reserve Bank of India, the Union of India and others, and left in place the Bombay High Court's decision that set aside the March 2020 write-down. This page summarises the judgment text and the press reports listed under Sources. It is an explainer, not legal advice, and it does not predict what the Court will do with the review petition. None of the sources we read gives a hearing date for it.

What an AT-1 bond is

The judgment describes AT-1 as part of a bank's Tier 1 capital under the RBI's Basel III Master Circular. Tier 1 is split into Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) and AT-1. The Court notes that banks must hold Tier 1 capital of at least 7% of risk-weighted assets, of which at least 5.5% must be CET1, and that the remaining 1.5% may optionally be met through AT-1.

AT-1 bonds are perpetual and can be written off or converted when a bank is in stress, which is why they carry higher coupons. The Court also records the two loss-absorption triggers in the bond documents: a pre-specified trigger (CET1 below 6.125% of risk-weighted assets for Yes Bank's bonds, on or after 31 March 2019) and a Point of Non-Viability (PONV) trigger, which the information memorandum says is determined by the RBI.

Timeline from the judgment and the press reports

Dates are as stated in the Supreme Court judgment unless the source column says otherwise.
DateEventSource
23 Dec 2016Yes Bank issues AT-1 bonds of Rs 3,000 croreJudgment, para 5
18 Oct 2017A further AT-1 tranche of Rs 5,415 croreJudgment, para 5
5 Mar 2020Moratorium imposed; RBI appoints an AdministratorJudgment, para 6
6 Mar 2020Draft reconstruction scheme published; its clause 6 said AT-1 instruments would be written down permanently, in fullJudgment, paras 6 and 20
13 Mar 2020Final Yes Bank Reconstruction Scheme notified; the write-down paragraph is absentJudgment, paras 7, 21 and 22
14 Mar 2020Administrator writes down the AT-1 bonds and informs BSE and NSEJudgment, para 8
20 Jan 2023Bombay High Court judgment setting aside the Administrator's actionJudgment, para 4
15 Oct 2026Supreme Court dismisses the appealsJudgment, paras 80 to 83
30 Oct 2026Bank's letter to Axis Trustee says it will take steps 'necessary and permissible under applicable law'Livemint, 13 Nov 2026
13 Nov 2026Yes Bank discloses the review petition to the exchangesLivemint and Reuters (via BusinessLine), 13 Nov 2026

What the Court decided, issue by issue

The judgment frames three issues. The table gives the Court's answer on each in plain words, drawn from the paragraphs cited.

IssueCourt's answerJudgment paras
Do later events (SBI's investment, the share price) make a decision on merits unnecessary?No. The Court tested the Administrator's act as it stood on 14 March 202012 to 16
Could the Administrator write down the bonds when the final scheme left out the write-down clause?No. The Court held the omission was a conscious decision and the general savings clause in clause 6(1) does not confer a specific power to write down17 to 42
Was the write-down consistent with the Master Circular and the bonds' information memorandum?No. The PONV decision belongs to the RBI, not the Administrator, and the circular's words 'before reconstitution' mean before the scheme takes effect43 to 73

Key reasoning, in the Court's words and ours

  • On the scheme: the Court said it had 'good reasons to infer' that the Central Government took a conscious decision to exclude the write-down clause after objections, and that the Administrator 'acted under an erroneous impression or mistaken belief' that he kept the power (para 40).
  • On timing: clause 2.15 of Annex 16 of the Master Circular says AT-1 instruments are to be converted or written down 'before amalgamation / reconstitution'. The Court read 'before' as before the scheme comes into force, not at any point in the following years (para 63).
  • On who decides: once the point of non-viability is reached, the Court said, the RBI, not the bank, determines the treatment, and the Administrator, who acts as a substitute for the board, could not take over that regulatory power (paras 69 to 73).
  • On necessity: the Court accepted that both the write-down and SBI's fund infusion may have been needed to revive the bank, but held that necessity does not excuse not following the prescribed manner (paras 75 and 77).
  • On the Court's scope: it clarified that its observations are for deciding these appeals only and that pending proceedings should proceed uninfluenced by them (para 83).

What the operative paragraphs say, and what they do not

Paragraph 80 dismisses the appeals and vacates any interim order. Paragraph 81 says the payment of the annual coupon rate 'shall remain unaffected by the outcome of these appeals and must be made in terms of the Information Memoranda'. Paragraph 82 leaves parties to bear their own costs.

Some press reports describe the judgment as ordering restoration of the bonds, for example Livemint on 13 November 2026 (restore 'with immediate effect') and BusinessToday on 16 October 2026 ('ordered the restoration'). We read the whole judgment text and did not find a separate restoration direction in paragraphs 80 to 83, so this page does not state the mechanics of restoration or any payment dates. Those are what the bondholders' trustee and the bank are in correspondence about, according to Livemint.

What the bank and the bondholders have said

Per Livemint (13 November 2026), the YES Bank AT-1 Bond Holders Association, which it says represents around 400 to 450 affected investors, and Axis Trustee Services have written to the bank asking for restoration of the bonds and payment of pending interest. Reuters, via BusinessLine (13 November 2026), reports that Axis Trustee had also filed a contempt petition in the Supreme Court a few days earlier, alleging the bank failed to give a 'concrete roadmap' for restoring the bonds.

Livemint (10 November 2026) reported that, nearly a month after the verdict, investors were still waiting for the bank to say when and how the bonds would be reinstated. Reuters (via BusinessLine) added that, after the judgment, it had reported that the bank was unlikely to pay coupons due on the bonds this year; that is Reuters' reporting, not a statement we found in the bank's disclosures.

The capital numbers the bank has given

The bank's own estimates of the capital effect are reported on different dates and bases, so they are shown separately and not merged.

FigureAs reportedSource
Pro forma effect of reinstating AT-1 principal on CET1 ratioAbout 240 basis points including profits, per MD and CEO Vinay Tonse on the earnings callLivemint, 13 Nov 2026
Pro forma effect, as stated by the bank after the verdict250 basis points on CET1 including profits, as at 30 June 2026BusinessToday, 16 Oct 2026
Capital adequacy ratio, 30 Sep 202614.5%Livemint, 13 Nov 2026
CET1 ratio, 30 Sep 202613.7%Livemint, 13 Nov 2026
Overall Tier 1 ratio, pro formaExpected to remain around 13.7%, per the CEOLivemint, 13 Nov 2026

Background the Court recorded about how the bonds were sold

The Court noted that the Master Circular specifies classes of investors to whom AT-1 instruments may be offered, and that the RBI treats them as high-risk securities for institutional investors. It said Yes Bank offered them to individual investors, referred to an email of 28 December 2016 placed on record, and noted that SEBI had imposed penalties on a private wealth management firm and on the then Managing Director for facilitating sales to individuals (para 79). It also recorded that, on 31 December 2019, the auditor's statement showed CET1 at 0.6% against a requirement of 7.375% (para 53).

What to watch, without guessing the outcome

  • Whether the Supreme Court lists and decides the review petition. The sources we read do not give dates.
  • Any further disclosures from Yes Bank to BSE and NSE on the bonds, coupons or capital.
  • Any order in the contempt petition reported by Reuters.
  • RBI or bank statements on how reinstated AT-1 capital would be treated.

Data notes

All judgment paragraph numbers refer to the Supreme Court's published PDF. Press figures are quoted with their outlet and date. Where outlets use different bases or dates, we show each. As of the publication date of this page, we had not seen the text of the bank's exchange disclosure on the review petition itself; the quotation attributed to the bank comes from Livemint's report of it.

Sources